Last week I was a guest on The Doctors along with weight-neutral endocrinologist Dr. Gregory Dodell. During the second half of the show, I was involved in a discussion with Dr. Melina Jampolis about the research supporting the weight loss paradigm, vs the research supporting the weight neutral health paradigm.
At one point during the course of the conversation I had listed several studies and their findings to support my case that the research shows that intentional weight loss fails the vast majority of the time (which Dr. Jampolis agreed with,) as well as studies that show greater efficacy of weight-neutral healthcare approaches than weight-loss approaches. (You can see a list of research at www.haeshealthsheets.com/resources)
In response Dr. Jampolis said “I’m sure that I could find 15 different studies that would counteract what you said.” Now, she didn’t name any studies at all but she sounded very confident. I wanted to interrupt but I didn’t want to appear rude, so I simply shook my head. I don’t believe that Dr. Jampolis wants to harm fat people, but I believe that she is, and this kind of misunderstanding is at the root of it.
There are many things that I could have done differently and/or better during my appearance (a post about that is probably coming up!) But the thing I regret the most is not interrupting her at this moment and saying what I wanted to say.
You can read the full piece on my new newsletter Weight and Healthcare on Substack!
UPCOMING ONLINE WORKSHOP:
Dealing With Fatphobia At The Holidays
Between in-person and online family gatherings, work parties, New Years bashes, New Years Resolution, and a ton of diet ads… the holiday season can be a perfect storm of fatphobia. Plus this year all the talk of COVID-related body changes adds another layer of nonsense All that diet culture can really get you down. In this workshop we’ll talk about tips, tricks, and techniques to help us deal and have a happy holiday season on our own terms – whether we celebrate any holidays or not.
Full details and Registration: https://danceswithfat.org/monthly-online-workshops/
*This workshop is free for DancesWithFat members – login info is on the member page
Become a member here!
Missed one of my monthly workshops? You can still get the video here!
Like This Blog? If you appreciate the work that I do, you can support my ability to do more of it with a one-time tip or by becoming a member. (Members get special deals on fat-positive stuff, a monthly e-mail keeping them up to date on the work their membership supports, and the ability to ask me questions that I answer in a members-only monthly Q&A Video!)
Book Me! I’d love to speak to your organization (and I can do it remotely!) I speak to healthcare, college, corporate, and general audiences about topics including weight science, weight stigma, and the Health at Every Size paradigm. You can get more information here or just e-mail me at ragen at danceswithfat dot org
4 thoughts on “Don’t Bring “Everybody Knows” to an Evidence Fight”
Save it for the inevitable next time. You know there will be more. 99.9% of Americans graduated with honors from Everybody Knows University. Most have their Master’s. You download the .99 cent thesis, “You Know What They Say.” do an internship at Wellduh, and you’re good to go.
“I’m sure I could find.” She probably could. Two Week studies, %3 success stories, highly redacted or outright falsehoods are as good as a viable juxtaposition when the speaker wants it to be true. (Not fact. They never do well on fact. But TRUTH is as good as gospel and just as rigorous.
‘In response Dr. Jampolis said “I’m sure that I could find 15 different studies that would counteract what you said.”’
Don’t forget to include the ones where dark chocolate accelerates your weight loss and fat people happen because dust!
Yes people need to find the actual research and not just ‘be sure’ it exists.
The War on Obesity could be a case study for the Dunning-Kruger effect. The less a person knows about weight science and size-based bigotry, the more smugly confident they are there’s no such thing as the latter and the former boils down to “bad choices = fat, good choices = thin.”